The Best Pie Pans For Baking: How To Find the Perfect Pie Pan
When looking to create the perfect pie, finding the right pie pan can sometimes be rather difficult. After my years of trial and error, I’ve gone through my fair share of baking pans, let alone pie pans and pie dishes.
Pies are an incredibly popular dessert and there’s so much you can do with them. So many different types of flavors, toppings, and options when it comes to baking a pie. On my website alone I have recipes for The Best Southern Pie Ever, Easy Cheeseburger Pie, Butterfinger Pie Recipe, Old Fashioned Banana Cream Pie, and much more.
My recipes on 78 recipes are designed to be quick, efficient, and something that anyone can do. Unfortunately, when it comes to all recipes, no matter how easy they really are, if you don’t have the proper equipment and tools, such as a pie dish, the recipe, unfortunately, won’t come out as intended. This is what this section of my website is all about, helping you find the perfect equipment and the tools that I use and love, to help you perform your best in the kitchen as well.
Below, you will find that I’ve listed a handful of amazing pie pan options so that you can find the perfect pan for your needs and know that you’re getting a high-quality pie that will last you years and years to come. There’s a variety of colors, shapes, designs, and materials so you can truly find the perfect pie pan for you and your baking needs. Whether you’re looking to bake your weekly apple pie or looking for the perfect dish for your pie for Thanksgiving, this post has got you covered.
Things You Should Consider
You may be wondering, what makes the perfect pan and what should I look out for when searching for my perfect pie pan for baking? Well, it’s pretty simple and we’ll list a few factors you should always consider down below.
How Easy It Is To Clean
One of the less than fun parts when it comes to baking and cooking, in my opinion, is the cleaning process. Not only is something quick and easy to clean ideal when it comes to baking pans especially, but it’s not just solely a convenience factor but also will affect the way you bake.
A lot of times when you bake, there tend to be leftover crumbs and pieces from your baking dish. If your pie dish isn’t the easiest to clean and there is leftover food residue on your dish, no matter how hard you scrub, this can affect the quality of your future baking dishes and potentially ruin them.
As more of an appearance thing, a clean dish without markings, stains, and food residue also holds up a lot better and looks really nice. So we prefer to find pie pans that are easier to clean.
Shape
When you think of pie pans, you may think that they’re all the same and that couldn’t be further from the truth. Yes, pie pans tend to have around the same style, but there are different types of pie pans with different crust designs and sizes and shapes.
There isn’t a perfect shape for everyone, but I tend to prefer the classic, ridge crust style pie pan as I think it’s extremely universal and great for everything from pumpkin pie to a breakfast quiche.
Presentation
I’m a firm believer that if it looks good, it probably tastes good as well! Although that’s not always the case, when it comes to eating, I do believe that presentation and appearance are really important and the second closest important factor when it comes to eating and enjoying food. You want to find a pie pan or baking dish that matches your style. Whether that be existing pots and pans you already have in your house, your kitchen colors or just something that you think looks really nice, presentation, even when it comes to bakeware is important.
Another important thing to remember is that with dishes like pies, you tend to serve them right in the baking dish instead of transferring them to another dish. This means that to save you the hassle of having to move it to a plate to make it look nicer if you get something that has some extra details and a pretty design, you can serve it happily right in the pie dish you baked it in.
The Best Pie Pans For Baking
Emile Henry Pie Dish
It’s hard to find the perfect high-quality pie dish, especially one that looks just as pretty as how practical it is. The Emile Henry Pie Dish has truly stolen the show when it comes to pie pans and is something that I think any baking enthusiast is sure to absolutely love.
The Good
This pie dish from Emile Henry will stand the test of time, and look great at the same time! Emile Henry Pie Dishes have been made in France since 1850 and are made from all-natural materials so you know that their pie dishes and pie pans are made of the highest quality on the market today.
This particular pie dish is made with burgundy clay using Emile Henry hr. Ceramic (high resistance). It has superior heat retention and also available in four different colors – which is perfect for matching your pie dish to your existing decor, pots, and pans, or your kitchen colors.
The Bad
The price. There’s a lot of affordable pie pan options on the market today that work great so if spending $50 for a single 9” pie pan is a little too steep for your wallet, there are tons of options available for much more affordable.
Although we find that this pan will last you years to come and well worth the price in our opinion, especially if you’re not an avid pie baker, we understand if it’s not something that is right for you.
| Pros | Cons |
| High-Quality Design | Price |
| All-Natural Materials | |
| High-Temperature Resistant |
4.0 out of 5.0 stars
Pyrex Easy Grip Glass Pie Pan
If you’re searching for that traditional glass style ie pan, we have the perfect option for you with this Pyrex Easy Grab 9.5” Pie Pan.
The Good
Glass pie pans are some of the most popular pans and have been for years. We especially love that this pie dish not only looks amazing but is extremely easy to bake with the easy to grab design. It’s a 9.5” pan which is great for a lot of different recipes and we simply cannot get over how amazing it looks when presented.
What’s also great? The pie pan has a limited 2-year warranty so you can use it every day and not have to stress about its quality. It’s also a microwave, dishwasher, oven, and freezer safe.
The Bad
Honestly, when it comes to this Pyrex Easy Grab 9.5” Pie Pan, we can’t really find too much to complain about. When it comes to the sizing, you may find some inconsistencies just with having a 9.5” style pie pan when most pie pans on the market today tend to be around 9” but that’s hardly an issue at all.
| Pros | Cons |
| Dishwasher Safe | Sizing may be inconsistent |
| Easy Grip Handles | |
| Beautiful Design |
4.5 out of 5.0 stars
Bruntmor Set of 2 Modern Ceramic Pie Pans
When it comes to more affordable pie pan options, we have just the perfect pan or should I say pans with this set of two Bruntmor Modern Ceramic Pie Pans.
The Good
The price is something that stands out to us when it comes to this Bruntmor Set of 2 Modern Ceramic Pie Pie set. For just under $25, you get not one but two amazing, high-quality pie pans that are perfect for baking anything from pies, tarts, to quiches.
A also absolutely love that the pans come in a variety of different colors so you can pick the perfect color to match your existing style and decor. The color is actually made from an eco-friendly varnish and is scratch-resistant so even with daily use, your pans will be holding up against the test of time.
The Bad
We typically like to go with pie pans that have a ridged or fun-style crust. We think that it adds a bit of elegance to any pie and unfortunately, this pie pan doesn’t have anything for the crust and instead is just a smooth surface.
| Pros | Cons |
| Great Price | No Design for Crust |
| Scratch Resistant | |
| Colors to Choose From |
4.5 out of 5.0 stars
KOOV Ceramic Pie Pan
If you’re looking for a pie pan that nearly looks just as good as the pie you’re baking, this dish from KOOV is just what you’re looking for. With an absolutely stunning design, your pie will definitely be the star of the show.
The Good
Firstly, we’ll start off with the stunning appearance of this KOOV Ceramic Pie Pan. This KOOV Ceramic Pie Pan is 9 inches and is perfect for pies, desserts, and even cooking dinner and certainly a great dish for making pie for Thanksgiving as well. It features a reactive glaze in a Nebula Blue shade that looks absolutely stunning when presenting your hard work!
We think that it’s a pretty good size for daily use with being 9” it’s the standard pie size and perfect for baking apple, blueberry, peace, and even, chicken pot pie. The ridging around the side of the pan also adds a nice effect when it comes to your crust details.
With such a beautiful color, you definitely don’t want it to fade over time. This long-lasting color is scratch resistant and is also actually made from an eco-friendly reactive glaze that is extremely high quality and safe under even the hottest of temperatures.
Lastly, what makes this pan so amazing, it’s extremely durable, microwavable safe, refrigerator, and dishwasher safe as well. It’s non-stick so clean-up is a breeze (something we said is very important when searching for the perfect pie pan) and is safe in the over for temperatures 500 degrees Fahrenheit or lower. Overall making this pan a fantastic pie pan option that not only looks amazing but performs amazing as well.
The Bad
Honestly, there aren’t many bad things to say about this high-quality KOOV pie pan. The only complaint that people may have is with the color selection available. This stunning pan would be even better if it was offered in other colors as well. We know that blue and this dark shade aren’t suitable for everyone’s style and therefore if there were a couple more color options, it would appeal to many more people. That being said, if blue is not normally your color choice, we still think that this Nebula Blue color is worth a chance!
| Pros | Cons |
| Long-Lasting Color | Only One Color Choice |
| Beautiful Design | |
| Eco-Friendly Glaze |
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
Overall Thoughts
With how many different pie pan options there are on the market today, I didn’t want a post that would overwhelm you with just as many options as you’d finding searching on Amazon yourself. The pie pans above are definitely some of the best on the market and I personally think that you’d be happy with any of the options, I know that I am!
I hope this post gave you some more insight about what to consider when shopping for a pie pan whether you’re looking for something to use every day or for the perfect baking dish for pie for Thanksgiving. It may seem like a silly task but if you’re looking to get more serious in the kitchen, you definitely want the right tools and equipment to avoid kitchen disasters.
