The Best Baking Sheets for Baking
Summary [ Click On Topic To Jump To It ]
When looking to create the perfect baked good whether it’s White Chocolate Strawberry and Oatmeal Cookies or Lazy Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars, finding the right baking sheet can sometimes be rather difficult. After my years of trial and error, I’ve gone through my fair share of baking pans, let alone baking sheets.
Baking is an incredibly popular pastime. Not only is it therapeutic for many individuals, but baking is also known as a result of celebrations. People bake for special occasions such as birthdays, holidays, special events, and sad events as well. Baking can cheer someone up instantly or show someone how much you truly care. For all the reasons and more, baking is extremely popular and done all over the world.
My recipes on 78 recipes are designed to be quick, efficient, and something that anyone can do. Unfortunately, when it comes to all recipes, no matter how easy they really are, if you don’t have the proper equipment and tools, such as a baking sheet, the recipe, unfortunately, won’t come out as intended. This is what this section of my website is all about, helping you find the perfect equipment and the tools that I use and love, to help you perform your best in the kitchen as well.
Below, you will find that I’ve listed a handful of the best baking sheets so that you can find the perfect pan for your needs and know that you’re getting a high-quality baked good that will last you years and years to come. There’s a variety of colors, shapes, designs, and materials so you can truly find the perfect baking sheet for you and your baking needs. Whether you’re looking for rimmed baking sheets or silicone baking sheets, this post has got you covered.
Things You Should Consider
You may be wondering, what makes the perfect baking sheet and what should I look out for when searching for my perfect baking sheet for baking? Well, it’s pretty simple and we’ll list a few factors you should always consider down below.
How Easy It Is To Clean
One of the least fun parts when it comes to baking and cooking, in my opinion, is the cleaning process. Not only is something quick and easy to clean ideal when it comes to baking pans especially, but it’s not just solely a convenience factor but also will affect the way you bake.
A lot of times when you bake, there tend to be leftover crumbs and pieces from your baking dish. If your baking sheet isn’t the easiest to clean and there is leftover food residue on your dish, no matter how hard you scrub, this can affect the quality of your future baking dishes and potentially ruin them.
As more of an appearance thing, a clean dish without markings, stains, and food residue also holds up a lot better and looks really nice. So we prefer to find baking sheets that are easier to clean.
Shape
When you think of baking sheets, you may think that they’re all the same and that couldn’t be further from the truth. Yes, baking sheets tend to have the same flat, rectangular shape, but there are a lot of sheets that vary in size and shape that can make a huge impact depending on what you’re looking to bake. Options include completely flat baking sheets, rimmed baking sheets, curved, bent and many others as well.
There isn’t a perfect shape for everyone, some people might want a rimmed baking sheet while others may prefer something more flush and flat. It just depends on your needs and baking preferences, but it is something important to take into consideration when making your purchase.
Presentation
I’m a firm believer that if it looks good, it probably tastes good as well! Although that’s not always the case, when it comes to eating, I do believe that presentation and appearance are really important and the second closest important factor when it comes to eating and enjoying food. I’ve talked about this many times on my website before for a number of different cooking products and necessities. You want to find a baking sheet or baking dish that matches your style. Whether that be existing pots and pans you already have in your house, your kitchen colors, or just something that you think looks really nice, presentation, even when it comes to bakeware is important.
The Best Baking Sheets For Baking
Nordic Ware Naturals Baking Sheets
It’s hard to find the perfect high-quality baking sheets for a great, affordable price. This baking sheet not only comes with one, high-quality baking sheet but two for one price. With custom size options available, this baking set may be your perfect solution.
The Good
Regardless of the baking sheet, you’re looking for, Nordic Ware Naturals features a variety of different size baking sheets so you are bound to find your best baking sheets option. With options for a big sheet with a rack, a baker 3 piece set, an Eighth Sheet, and many other options, when it comes to finding the best baking sheets, look no further than Nordic Ware Naturals.
The Naturals commercial bakeware is made from the highest quality pure aluminum which will never rust in its lifetime. That’s a pretty bold promise, but the pans seem to hold up to that promise. With a lifetime of durability, you can cook all the sweet and savory dishes right on this baking pan without any hassle. Cleaning is a breeze, but hand wash is recommended with these pans. It is compatible with both parchment paper and silicone baking mats so although it’s not a silicone baking sheet you can use a reusable silicone mat right on top of it and make cleaning even easier.
The Bad
There are not a lot of bad things to say about this set of 2 baking sheets, especially because they’re some of the best baking sheets available on the market today. That being said, the price is definitely not the cheapest price for baking sheets. However, you get what you pay for and if you break it down per sheet, you’re paying about $20 for one great baking sheet, and 2 for a little over $40.
| Pros | Cons |
| High-Quality Design | Price |
| Lifetime Rust Proof Guarantee | |
| Large Capacity |
4.5 out of 5.0 stars
Rachael Ray Bakeware Non-Stick Cookie Pan Set
Rachael Ray is a well-known name in the cooking industry. With her cooking show on cable and her line of high-quality and highly rated cooking products, her Non-Stick Cookie Pan Set is one of the top-rated baking sheets on Amazon today with over 12,000+ nearly 5-star rating.
The Good
Rachael Rays products all have pretty great ratings! She is well loved not only for her TV show but also for her high quality products so you can follow her recipes right in the comfort of your home. This 3 piece cookie pan set is one of the best baking sheets money can buy. It features a variety of features that make your life easier when it comes to baking.
It has an easy food release that’s features a long-lasting all over nonstick coating that makes for easy food release and easy clean up as well. This nonstick coating is meant to last for years and years to ome.
It’s also designed as a feel good baking set. A portion of the proceeds from every baking set goes towards Rachael’s nonprofit that goes towards families and helping to promote a healthy relationship with food.
Lastly, the grip that’s included on the pan made from a comfortable and confident grasp on your baking pans when you take them in and out of the oven. The pan itself is suitable for up to 500 degrees fahrenheiht.
The Bad
If blue isn’t your color, you could not be the biggest fan of the grips that are on the pans. Other than that, there isn’t much to complain about at all. We couldn’t really find anything and neither could the over 12,000 people who reviewed the pan on Amazon.
| Pros | Cons |
| Nonstick Coating | Color Choices |
| Easy Cleanup | |
| Set of 3 |
4.5 out of 5.0 stars
Betty Crocker Set of 3 Non-Stick Cookie and Baking Sheets
Betty Crocker is another well known baking company brand, if not the best, well-known baking company out there. With years and years of leading the industry when it comes to the best baking sheets and dishes, you know when ordering something from Betty Crocker you’re getting high-quality and something that is well-loved by millions.
The Good
Another set of 3 pans, these Betty Crocker baking sheets make some of the best baking sheets on the market regardless of them not being silicone baking sheets. These rimmed baking sheets are some of the most affordable baking sheets, especially for a set of 3 high-quality sheets. They are dishwasher safe which makes for exceptionally easy cleanup and also features the non-stick coating that we talked about and should be included on the best baking sheets. In this set of 3, you get a large sheet, a medium sheet, and a small sheet so you don’t need to use a huge baking sheet if you’re just making a small baked good. Another way to cut down on cleaning time.
These pans feature 4-sided easy grip edges which makes handling the sheets in and out of the oven a breeze and eliminate any stress of dropping your freshly baked goods on the floor.
Betty Crocker states that this set is suitable for all baking needs and once purchased will solve all your baking needs. We definitely agree with this.
The Bad
Along with mostly all of the other baking sheet options listed above, we can’t find anything wrong with these baking sheets. Especially when it comes to quality, ease of use, and of course the price, this baking sheet set is by far some of the best baking sheets available on the market today.
| Pros | Cons |
| Great Price | Nothing! |
| Set of 3 | |
| Dishwasher Safe |
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
Wilton Perfect Results Nonstick Cookie Pan
If you’re looking for perfection when it comes to a baking sheet, look no further than Wilton Perfect Results Nonstick Cookie pan, your ideal baking sheet.
The Good
If you’re looking for just one solid option when it comes to a baking sheet this one from Wilton is designed to perform exceptional and result in perfect results, hence the name. It’s a nonstick cookie pan that features a nonstick surface that offers reinforced coating so that your cookies or baked goods come off extremely easy and are exceptionally easy to clean up. It features convenient handles that are designed for you to have a confident grip regardless of if you’re moving the pan in or out of the oven, wearing or not wearing oven mitts. It features a heavy, strong construction designing the pan to be ideal for years and years of consistent use.
The pan measurements are permanently stamped right on the pan which makes following recipes even easier. It’s affordable and definitely a perfect option if you’re looking to achieve perfect results!
The Bad
Just like the other baking pans that we’ve mentioned above, there aren’t necessarily bad things about this pan. One area that you may consider other options is the fact that it’s only a single pan in this purchase. So if you’re looking to bake multiple items, you have to purchase multiple pans whereas the other pans above have several pans in the set. Most people tend to have multiple baking sheets so this is probably something that you have to invest in and take into consideration when looking to purchase a new baking sheet set.
| Pros | Cons |
| Long-Lasting Color | Only One |
| Beautiful Design | Small Size |
| Eco-Friendly Glaze |
5.0 out of 5.0 stars
Overall Thoughts
With how many different baking sheet options there are on the market today, I didn’t want a post that would overwhelm you with just as many options as you’d finding searching on Amazon yourself. The baking sheet above are definitely some of the best on the market and I personally think that you’d be happy with any of the options, I know that I am!
I hope this post gave you some more insight about what to consider when shopping for baking sheets whether you’re looking for rimmed baking sheets or silicone baking sheets. It may seem like a silly task but if you’re looking to get more serious in the kitchen, you definitely want the right tools and equipment to avoid kitchen disasters.
